Scribus > Vector graphics and postscript

scribus vs inkscape

<< < (2/2)

utnik:
hi guillaume

it's a good thing, that the vector drawing and editing tools of 'inkscape' are completely different from the vector tools of 'scribus'.
here the difference should be a good reason to dowmload 'inkscape', as the vector editing abilities of 'scribus' are more or less crippled.

if you do a lot of vector work, you'll need a vector tool (which scribus isn't…)

utnik

GarryP:
Just to add my two-penneth to the discussion: I've used Scribus to create quite a bit of vector artwork - see the Showcase section of this forum for some examples - but I wouldn't recommend using it to create anything of a non-trivial nature. While it is possible to create vector artwork in Scribus, and the tools available are - to differing extents - quite sophisticated, the process can be a bit of a chore.

Scribus lacks many tools and options that make creating vector artwork a pleasurable experience. For instance, snapping is very limited compared to other software - Inkscape included - and the way Scribus manages colours can make the creative process a much longer drawn-out affair than it could otherwise be.

Think of the two applications being used by two different people: Inkscape for the graphic artist; Scribus for the layout guy. The Scribus vector tools are more for tweaking the artwork than creating it. Ask utnik said above, Scribus isn't a vector tool. It has some vector editing capabilities but they are very limited compared to other software. To try and put this another way: GIMP has text editing facilities but you wouldn't normally use it as a document layout tool (although I have heard about some people doing so). Use the right software for the job and things will be easier.

If you have the opportunity to learn how to use both Scribus and Inkscape then that's what I would recommend. Draw vector artwork in Inkscape and import it into Scribus for layout. If you can only learn Scribus then be prepared to do a lot more work to get what you want. Learning two applications takes more time than only learning one but you'll be making things easier for yourself in the long-run.

NOTE: Scribus can't properly render everything that Inkscape can produce, such as transparencies. Make sure you import your Inkscape work into a blank Scribus document every now and again just to make sure it will be handled properly.

Navigation

[0] Message Index

[*] Previous page

Go to full version